An overbilled line looks like all the others. It becomes visible when the price is held against the agreement. In more than 50,000 manually reviewed invoices there were errors in more than 10% of the invoices, and typically 1.6% of the purchase total was over-invoiced. What that is in kroner is shown in what errors on supplier invoices cost (in Danish). The examples are Danish: prices in Danish kroner (DKK) and Danish law.
What is overbilling?
Overbilling is when the supplier invoices more than you have agreed. The yardstick is the agreement that applied when you bought: the price agreement, the discount rate, the quote or the order confirmation.
If you have no agreement on an item, you must pay the price the supplier asks, unless it is unreasonable (the Danish Sale of Goods Act, købeloven, section 5). A price increase is then not overbilling in itself. Measure the price against what you have paid before. If you disagree with the price, say so as soon as the invoice arrives. Otherwise you may be bound by it (Sale of Goods Act, section 6).
Overbilling is not the same as fraud. Invoice fraud is a fake invoice or a fake message about a new account number, and it needs a different control. See invoice fraud with a new account number (in Danish). Overbilling comes from a supplier you trade with and need not be deliberate. It can, for example, be an agreement that has not been entered correctly at the supplier.
Duplicate invoices, fees without an agreement and the wrong quantity are also overbilling. They are covered with the other typical errors in 7 typical errors on supplier invoices (in Danish). Here we look at the five forms that concern the price and the credit note.
Five forms of overbilling
The examples use made-up figures.
Wrong price compared with the price agreement
The line has a net price, but not the agreed one, for example an old price or a price from another agreement. If the agreed price is DKK 66.50 and the invoice says DKK 72.00, that is DKK 5.50 too much per piece and DKK 330.00 for 60 pieces. See how to find the price that applied.
The discount has not been deducted
The agreement gives a discount rate on the gross price, but the rate is missing from the line or is too low. If the agreement gives a 35% discount on a brand, and the item has a gross price of DKK 180.00, you should pay DKK 117.00. If the supplier deducts just 25%, you pay DKK 135.00, and for 12 pieces that is DKK 216.00 too much. If the invoice shows the net price alone, you cannot see the rate on the line. See gross price, net price and discount rate (in Danish).
Price increase before the notice date
The new price appears on invoices from before the date in the price notice, or a fixed agreed price rises without the agreement allowing it. If the supplier gives notice of 5% from 1 March, the old price of DKK 320.00 applies until then. If the item is at DKK 336.00 on an invoice from 20 February, that is DKK 16.00 too much per piece and DKK 128.00 for 8 pieces. Whether the price may rise from 1 March depends on your agreement. Which date counts is stated in the agreement or in the supplier's terms of sale. See price notice from the supplier (in Danish).
List price instead of the agreed price
The item is invoiced at the supplier's list price, as if there were no agreement. This happens, for example, when it has been ordered under another customer number or has been given a new item number. If the list price is DKK 249.00 and the agreed price DKK 189.00, 12 pieces are invoiced DKK 720.00 too high. See error no. 1 in 7 typical errors on supplier invoices (in Danish).
Missing credit note after a complaint
The fifth form is not a new error on the invoice, but a correction that does not come. You have complained, and the supplier has said yes, but the credit note does not arrive or covers just part of the claim. Take the claim of DKK 330.00 from the wrong-price example. If 40 of the 60 pieces are credited, the credit note is for DKK 220.00, and DKK 110.00 is still missing. A credit note for returned goods or pallets does not cover a price difference. See credit note for an incorrect invoice (in Danish).
How to check it yourselves
Hold every line against the agreement that applied when you bought. Find the item by its item number, and convert both prices to the same unit. Compare the lines, not just the total. A correct total can hide wrong prices. The full method with a checklist is in the guide to checking supplier invoices, and converting units in step 2. Keep the order confirmations. If you have the invoice and nothing else, use the invoice date to find the agreement that applied.
If the price has been entered wrongly at the supplier, it is wrong on every invoice with the item until it is corrected. So find the other invoices with the item, and include them in the same claim.
Send the supplier the lines, the agreement and the difference in kroner as soon as you find the deviation, preferably before you pay. Ask for a credit note, and ask the supplier to correct the price in its system, so the error does not come back. Do not close the case until the credit note has arrived and covers the difference.
How far back can you claim the money?
A claim for money you have overpaid becomes time-barred under the Danish Limitation Act (forældelsesloven). The general limitation period is 3 years (section 3). It runs from the earliest time you could claim the money (section 2). If you did not know that you had overpaid, the period runs from the day you learned or ought to have learned of it (section 3(2)). The claim is, however, time-barred no later than 10 years after the time you could claim the money, even if you discover the error later (section 3(3), no. 4). If the supplier acknowledges the claim, the limitation period is interrupted (section 15).
If you have not agreed the price, you may have lost the claim long before. In a commercial sale, a sale between two businesses in the course of their trade, you must object to the price on the invoice as soon as you can. Otherwise you must pay it, unless it is clearly unreasonable (Sale of Goods Act, sections 4 and 6). The rule does not apply when a lower price has been agreed. So check the invoice when it arrives.
Between two businesses, an agreement can set a shorter period. The Limitation Act cannot be departed from in advance to the detriment of the debtor (section 26). Here the debtor is the supplier, and a shorter period is to the supplier's advantage. So check your agreement and the supplier's terms of sale. You must also be able to show the agreement that applied at the time. If you are in doubt in a specific case, ask a lawyer.
How DiFacto does it
DiFacto holds every item line on every invoice against your price agreements. Items without an agreement are measured against what you have paid for them on earlier invoices in DiFacto. If there is neither an agreed price nor enough earlier purchases to measure against, the line is shown as «No comparison». Every deviation is shown with the price it is measured against, the invoiced price and the difference in kroner, and you can dismiss a false alarm. If the agreement is a percentage discount on a brand, and the invoice shows the net price alone, the system cannot check the line against the rate. It is counted as unchecked.
In DiFacto you can upload a price notice under the supplier's price agreements. It is stored as documentation and never becomes agreed prices. A finding after the notice date can be dismissed as «Notified price increase». If at least five items have been bought at a price above the agreement in the last 60 days, the system reminds you to ask the supplier for new prices.
If a credit note mentions the invoice, the system suggests which open claim it answers. You settle what has been paid back, and the rest stays as a claim under «Outstanding» on the dashboard. Invoices come in by upload or, with the AutoPilot add-on, via your own DiFacto email address, as a PDF, an image or an e-invoice.
If we do not find errors worth more than the subscription, the difference is credited. The price is in the price calculator under Priser (in Danish). Read more in DiFacto in English, and in Danish about fakturakontrol and price agreements in DiFacto. If you want to compare several tools, see tools that check supplier invoices against price agreements.